Genetically modified debate will not be resolved through trade negotiations

By 
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: June 16, 2011

The European Union’s ambassador to Canada said Canadian farmers should not expect free trade talks to solve key outstanding issues between the two.

Matthias Brinkmann, speaking at an event organized by the University of Saskatchewan’s Johnson Shoyama Graduate School of Public Policy on May 25, cited Canadian and EU differences on genetically modified organisms as one example. Europe’s ban on most GMOs has long been a source of consternation for Canadian farmers but Brinkmann said the issue would not be resolved through a trade negotiations. Instead, the European Parliament would have to change its laws.

Read Also

Aaron Beattie is an oat and barley breeder with the Crop Development Centre at the University of Saskatchewan. He spoke to farmers and media at Ag In Motion, a farm show held near Langham, Sask. from July 15-17

Cereal drought tolerant ratings hard to compile

Cereals and most crops have ratings for disease resistance, yield potential, straw height and other traits, but not drought tolerance. Right now, that sort of information is anecdotal

Brinkmann also indicated that Europe’s disdain for hormone treated meat was unlikely to change. He said the ban on hormone treated beef and pork was the result of public opposition and EU legislators were following the wishes of their electorate.

He said even if hormone treated meat were allowed in, he doubted Europeans would buy it.

He added that access for a “generous” quota of hormone-free Canadian beef could be negotiated.

“But we want something in return. We open for your beef, you open for our cheeses,” he said, referring to the entrenched supply management system that regulates the Canadian dairy, poultry and egg industries.

He said doing away with supply management in the wake of an agreement was unlikely, but the negotiations would require concessions from both sides, and issues like the GMO and hormone bans would have to be worked around.

Brinkmann said Canada has a lot to gain from a deal with the EU, the world’s largest economy, representing a market of about 500 million people.

As well, development needs in new EU member states and potential new EU members in the Balkans represent massive opportunities for the Canadian economy, he said.

From its perspective, the EU sees access to Canada’s public works projects as the biggest potential prize of a deal.

He tried to soothe fears that this would prevent municipal and provincial governments from buying local, saying European firms would want to bid on large-scale public projects, which would increase competition and save taxpayers money.

About the author

Bryn Levy

University Of Minnesota Extension

explore

Stories from our other publications