Cartier should have place in hall of fame

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: September 16, 2010

,

Immanuel Giulea and James McLean, authors of this opinion, are members of the Sociéte Macdonald-Cartier Society, a non-profit group with a mandate to educate citizens about Canadian history, heritage and culture.

George-Etienne Cartier deserves his place in the Canadian Railway Hall of Fame.

When most Canadians take a minute to think about the railway development in our country and how the transcontinental rail came to be, they think of Sir John A. Macdonald.

What most Canadians are unaware of is that Macdonald wasn’t behind the Canadian Pacific Railroad that linked the east coast all the way to Vancouver. It was Macdonald’s close ally, George-tienne Cartier, who played the greatest role.

Read Also

Spencer Harris (green shirt) speaks with attendees at the Nutrien Ag Solutions crop plots at Ag in Motion on July 16, 2025. Photo: Greg Berg

Interest in biological crop inputs continues to grow

It was only a few years ago that interest in alternative methods such as biologicals to boost a crop’s nutrient…

Cartier, recognized as an influential leader, understood that the key to prosperity in both pre-and post-Confederation Canada lay in the construction of railways. He devoted much of his professional life to raising money, building public support and representing the interests of the railway industry in the union and federal legislatures.

For nearly two decades, Cartier acted as the solicitor to the Grand Trunk Railroad and mobilized his law firm to act on its behalf. Acting as its legal agent, Cartier’s firm dealt with labour disputes, property litigations, court cases, inquests and land deals.

On every significant legal issue the Grand Trunk faced during pre-Confederation Canada, Cartier and his firm fought in the interests of railways and the economic development they brought. More than just providing legal counsel, Cartier also became a spokesperson for the railway industry.

In 1845, Cartier was appointed first solicitor of the St. Lawrence and Atlantic Railway, a line that would connect Montreal with the ice-free port of Portland, Maine.

A few years later, as chief solicitor of the Grand Trunk Railway, he actively promoted the financing of the Grand Trunk and Intercolonial railways through government loans and subsidies.

From 1851 to his death in 1873, not counting short intervals out of power, Cartier was chair of the Standing Committee on Railways. Shortly after Confederation, he signaled that his intentions to champion railway interests would continue. As minister of militia before and after the union, he promoted railways as a necessity for national security and unity.

In 1870, he persuaded British Columbia delegates to join Confederation by promising that a CP rail connection would begin in three years.

Working with British financiers, the Bank of Montreal and Hudson’s Bay Company interests, Cartier actively promoted the CPR. Two years later, in 1872, Cartier introduced and pushed the bill that created the CPR through the House of Commons.

Influential in the drafting of clauses in various acts, including the BNA Act, Cartier prevented U.S. lines from tapping into Canadian east-west trade until the Grand Trunk, Intercolonial and CPR were underway.

A year before his death, Cartier lost his election in Montreal-East. Most people don’t know he was defeated by the interest of Boston financiers who wanted to build a transcontinental railway through Quebec and Ontario. The lobbying from Boston to build the Northern Pacific Railroad eventually led to the Pacific Scandal. Cartier was defeated but later given the riding of Provencher.

For all his achievements, Canada owes a great deal of gratitude to this leader who played such an influential role in shaping our nation’s economic and railway history.

For his role in the railway development of Canada, George-Etienne Cartier fully deserves his place in the Canadian Railway Hall of Fame, next to other great leaders such as Sir John A. Macdonald, George Stephen, Donald Smith and others.

About the author

Immanuel Giulea

Freelance Contributor

explore

Stories from our other publications