Hog silence proves techniques work

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: December 12, 2002

OLDS, Alta. – When Temple Grandin toured an American IBP hog plant

recently, it was so quiet she thought she must have arrived during

lunch break. The animal welfare expert didn’t hear any pigs squealing,

gates slamming or workers yelling to move pigs up the alleys.

Then she saw the hogs walking through the chute quietly.

“They had fixed all the little details,” said Grandin, who was excited

about how calmly the animals acted.

Staff at the plant had removed the distractions that cause hogs to

Read Also

Spencer Harris (green shirt) speaks with attendees at the Nutrien Ag Solutions crop plots at Ag in Motion on July 16, 2025. Photo: Greg Berg

Interest in biological crop inputs continues to grow

It was only a few years ago that interest in alternative methods such as biologicals to boost a crop’s nutrient…

balk, lights were added to eliminate black holes and shadows, and

non-slip flooring was laid down.

“Details matter to animals,” said Grandin. She has spent much time in

slaughter plants fixing things that improve the efficiency and the ease

with which animals move without getting poked or prodded.

After 30 years of promoting good livestock management, it seemed there

was a breakthrough in the way livestock are handled.

“Sometimes I felt like I was bashing my head against the wall,” said

Grandin.

Animal welfare has generally improved since she became the scientific

adviser for the American Meat Institute and started working with large

restaurant chains like McDonalds and Burger King, Grandin said.

For example, in 1996 only 30 percent of slaughter plants had an

effective beef cattle stunning efficacy. After McDonald’s got involved

in 1999, 90 percent passed a welfare audit.

It boils down to the attitude of managers, said Grandin, who insists

facility audits must continue to prevent reversion to bad habits.

“It’s just been absolutely amazing, the improvement.”

But she also said more work is needed. A 1997 livestock council

declaration in Rome will continue to focus the world on the welfare of

animals, she said.

The council said animals are “sentient beings,” not just goods. An

animal is not a desk or a chair.

“The legal status of animals is definitely changing,” Grandin told an

Alberta Farm Animal Care conference at Olds College.

One of her measures is the “Chicago airport test.” What would 10

people, randomly sampled from the Chicago airport, think about an issue?

During a flight on an American airline, Grandin showed pictures to the

people sitting in the seats next to her of sows in farrowing crates and

sows in multiple-sow pens.

One-third had no opinion about the sows in farrowing crates. One-third

were mildly opposed and one-third hated them.

Crates don’t allow sows to turn around, said Grandin, who compared a

good sow stall to a business class seat in an airplane and a poor stall

to a seat at the back of a crowded plane with little leg room.

Most people were satisfied with the condition of pigs housed in groups

on concrete slats, but “sow stalls don’t pass the ethical test.”

explore

Stories from our other publications