Your reading list

Industries want Senate to reject amendments

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: November 20, 2024

Bill C-282, a private member’s bill, calls for dairy, egg and poultry production to be protected in future trade negotiations. Earlier this month, the Senate foreign affairs committee agreed to changes that made the bill meaningless.  |  File photo

Dairy, egg and poultry producers say their sectors are at risk if Bill C-282 isn’t passed 
in its original form

REGINA — Supply managed sectors say they’re disappointed with amendments to Bill C-282.

The Senate foreign affairs committee earlier this month agreed in a 10-3 vote to changes that they say made the bill meaningless.

The private member’s bill calls for dairy, egg and poultry production to be protected in future trade negotiations but the changes mean it wouldn’t apply to existing and renegotiated agreements or those currently in negotiation.

Read Also

From left New Brunswick agriculture minister Pat Finnigan, PEI minister Bloyce Thompson, Alberta minister RJ Sigurdson, Ontario minister Trevor Jones, Manitoba minister Ron Kostyshyn, federal minister Heath MacDonald, BC minister Lana Popham, Sask minister Daryl Harrison, Nova Scotia Greg Morrow and John Streicker from Yukon.

Agriculture ministers commit to enhancing competitiveness

Canadian ag ministers said they want to ensure farmers, ranchers and processors are competitive through ongoing regulatory reform and business risk management programs that work.

In the last three agreements with Europe, North America and the TransPacific, Canada increased market access to those industries and consequently is paying billions in compensation. The government has committed $4.8 billion to farmers and processors.

During its deliberations, the committee was told the bill was bad trade policy because it tied negotiators’ hands. Canadian agriculture is overwhelmingly export dependent. For example, 90 per cent of canola production leaves the country.

But the five organizations representing farmers in the supply managed system called the amendments heavy handed.

A statement from the Egg Farmers of Canada, Chicken Farmers of Canada, Turkey Farmers of Canada, Dairy Farmers of Canada and Canadian Hatching Egg Producers said the bill would safeguard farmers and ensure a stable and predictable supply of food.

“We urge senators to reject the committee amendments and support Bill C-282 in its original form,” they said.

The bill will go to the Senate as a whole and face more scrutiny. It could be amended again and then would go back to the House of Commons for third reading.

Time is running out for that, however, as the Bloc Quebecois has said the original C-282 must be passed in order for it to maintain its support of the minority Liberal government.

Both houses were on a break last week but government business has been at a standstill for weeks due to Conservative delaying tactics.

Another consideration is the new Trump administration south of the border and what that might mean for the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement.

Meanwhile, the Canadian Agri-Food Trade Alliance said it welcomed the amendments because the original bill would have posed a direct threat to the sector.

Ninety per cent of Canadian farmers rely on trade, CAFTA said.

About the author

Karen Briere

Karen Briere

Karen Briere grew up in Canora, Sask. where her family had a grain and cattle operation. She has a degree in journalism from the University of Regina and has spent more than 30 years covering agriculture from the Western Producer’s Regina bureau.

explore

Stories from our other publications