Animal welfare, animal rights – Editorial Notebook

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: January 24, 2002

$17.5 million is a lot of money. That was the size of the operating

budget last year for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals.

Dr. John Church, animal welfare specialist with Alberta Agriculture,

brought that statistic to his presentation to the Farm Animal Council

of Saskatchewan meeting two weeks ago. Most of PETA’s money goes to

spreading its message of animal rights, he said, with a relatively

small portion used for animal rescue and other expenses.

Now PETA is taking on the livestock industry in North America.

Read Also

A wheat field is partially flooded.

Topsy-turvy precipitation this year challenges crop predictions

Rainfall can vary dramatically over a short distance. Precipitation maps can’t catch all the deviations, but they do provide a broad perspective.

Witness the recent anti-milk campaign aimed at schoolchildren and

various anti-beef campaigns.

Church sees five points on the scale of human philosophies toward

animals. Abolitionists are on one end, believing animals have the same

rights as people and should not be used for any purpose.

There aren’t many abolitionists.

At the other end are dominionists, who believe people can do whatever

they want with animals because humans are the only species with rights.

There aren’t many dominionists either.

Most people fall into the central categories: animal rightists and

animal welfarists. As Church defines it, animal rightists believe

humans should not make use of animals except when it benefits the

animal or is mutually beneficial to animal and human.

Animal welfarists believe people can use animals, but they have a

responsibility for animals’ well being and to provide for their basic

needs.

Church says there are signs that sentiment is shifting toward the

animal rightist side and away from the welfarist segment occupied by

livestock producers.

Small wonder, when people are further removed from farms and food

sources, and when kids are raised on movies like Babe and Chicken Run

that essentially denounce the meat industry.

When we extol the virtues of animal welfare in this newspaper, we are

preaching to the converted. Livestock producers know there’s no

percentage – financially or morally – in mistreating animals.

Yet with PETA and like organizations spending millions on their

message, it becomes ever more crucial that livestock producers police

themselves and examine their operations carefully.

Farm animal councils are an excellent way to research animal welfare

issues and provide that information to producers.

There has never been a better time to get involved.

About the author

Barb Glen

Barb Glen

Barb Glen is the livestock editor for The Western Producer and also manages the newsroom. She grew up in southern Alberta on a mixed-operation farm where her family raised cattle and produced grain.

explore

Stories from our other publications