Enforce standards or damage organics – WP editorial

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: September 5, 2002

Whether they entered because of philosophy or in pursuit of profit,

farmers in organic food production are helping transform it from a

niche into a mainstream market.

However, if Canadian farmers and certification bodies aren’t more

vigilant in meeting or enforcing national and

international organic standards, a small handful of farmers could

jeopardize a multi-billion dollar industry that still possesses great

potential at a time when the traditional farm economy is facing

challenges.

Read Also

A wheat field is partially flooded.

Topsy-turvy precipitation this year challenges crop predictions

Rainfall can vary dramatically over a short distance. Precipitation maps can’t catch all the deviations, but they do provide a broad perspective.

In Canada, there are $1 billion worth of organic sales annually, with

half of that being purchased in supermarkets.

According to speakers at the International Federation of Organic

Movements world congress in Victoria recently, more than 42 million

acres of land are managed organically in the world, and the world

retail market for organic food and beverages was an estimated $17.5

billion US in 2000.

Organic products are seen as an area of great opportunity, with an

annual global growth rate expected at about 20 percent.

One success story was Horizon Organic, an American company founded in

1991 with its first product being organic yogurt. A decade later, the

company had sales of $159 million US and its products appeared in 55

percent of U.S. supermarkets. The company has expanded its business

across North America, the United Kingdom and Japan.

Most organic producers probably have less modest goals for their

businesses, but they still recognize the potential.

But the key is consumers. They desire more choice and healthier

products. They trust farmers to deliver products grown without

chemicals and in an environmentally friendly manner.

Recently, some Canadian organic inspectors raised serious concerns that

a small number of Canadian organic producers may be accidentally or

intentionally not meeting or cheating the guidelines. There are about

50 certification bodies in Canada and while some enforce strict

standards and tough laws, others are more slack.

There needs to be more information and research delivered to farmers

about organic production systems, but even more critical is the need to

have and follow certification systems that adhere to strict

international standards.

The certification bodies themselves acknowledge there needs to be more

vigilance, and there have been some recent changes.

But some inspectors recommend additional random, surprise audits;

sampling of plants to test for chemical residues; and more follow-up

tests and checks for farms who raised suspicions during annual audits.

The certification bodies bear responsibility to enforce standards, and

there should be standardization among certification bodies. Producers

have complained that audits are cumbersome, awkward and expensive.

Perhaps the audit system needs to be improved.

Canadian organic farmers need to avoid honest mistakes and cheating.

The future of a successful market relies on credibility, trust and

integrity in the eyes of the consumer.

explore

Stories from our other publications