Train collision worries residents

By 
Reading Time: 3 minutes

Published: May 9, 2002

FIRDALE, Man. – Residents of two Manitoba communities are worried about

the possible long-term health effects of a May 2 truck-train collision.

A semi-trailer and Canadian National train collided at an uncontrolled

intersection near Firdale, 130 kilometres west of Winnipeg.

The train included four cars of benzene, one car of hexane and several

cars of plastic pellets.

The burning chemicals forced the evacuation of a Hutterite colony, 170

Firdale area residents and another 30 residents in the nearby community

Read Also

Agriculture ministers have agreed to work on improving AgriStability to help with trade challenges Canadian farmers are currently facing, particularly from China and the United States. Photo: Robin Booker

Agriculture ministers agree to AgriStability changes

federal government proposed several months ago to increase the compensation rate from 80 to 90 per cent and double the maximum payment from $3 million to $6 million

of Edrans.

Despite assurances that the air and water around their homes would be

safe, residents who live near the crash site wonder what kind of

contamination the two-day chemical fire will leave.

“I’m worried about what’s laying on the ground,” said Jerry Peters, a

cattle producer who farms two kilometres from the crash site.

“Why wouldn’t they let people go home if the smoke was so harmless?”

Peters’ first concern was for his wife and two young boys, but he also

worried about his cattle and whether there will be long-term health

consequences for his livestock. He had cattle on pasture downstream

from the fire.

“They had access to water, but we don’t know what’s in it.”

Benzene is toxic, said Chuck Sanderson of the Manitoba Emergency

Measures Organization, but the chemical loses its toxicity as it

disperses and burns off.

Area residents were advised to wear rubber gloves and use soap and

water to wash away dust and ash found in their homes. Health officials

said the measure was only a precaution and that the dust was not

harmful.

While many residents were allowed home May 3, others weren’t so lucky.

Henry Peters couldn’t return to his farm until May 4.

He witnessed the collision, which started as a sequence of small booms

and then erupted into a large fireball that blasted into the air.

“After that, it was black billowing smoke,” Peters said.

About two hours after the collision, Peters was ordered to leave his

farm, where he keeps cattle and 500 laying hens.

“We had two minutes to get out,” he said of the evacuation. “They

wouldn’t let us do anything.”

He was allowed to return home briefly the following day, but it was not

until the next evening that he returned home permanently.

Being forced from his farm was more than an inconvenience. He had no

chance to get water to his cattle while he away. As well, power to his

farm was cut off and his laying hens were without feed and water.

George and Catherine Froese were also kept out of their home for more

than two days. When the evacuation order came, they had only enough

time to pack some clothes and personal effects. Their pets, including

dogs, cats and an iguana, were left behind.

The Froeses stayed with friends at a farm near MacGregor, Man.

Catherine managed to stay in good spirits while she was away from home,

despite the worry about what would become of her pets.

“It’s kind of nice having someone doing the cooking and laundry for

you,” she joked about an hour before learning they could return home.

She said one of their first priorities would be having the water at

their home tested to ensure it was safe for drinking.

The train crew and the truck driver were not injured in the accident.

An investigation is under way.

Volunteer firefighters from across the province helped fight the toxic

inferno. Water bombers were also used.

“We pulled it off without anyone getting hurt,” said a weary Gerry

Currie, fire chief for one of the local volunteer fire departments.

“We did the best we could. It’s unbelievable what’s involved.”

Aside from contending with the burning train wreckage, firefighters

also were needed May 3 to fight a machine shed fire and a brush fire in

the area.

A CN official said evacuees seeking compensation for expenses such as

lodging, meals or injured livestock should submit expenses to their

local municipal office. The municipality will forward the expenses to

CN, which will compensate those who qualify.

The CN official emphasized the compensation offer didn’t mean the

company was accepting blame for the crash.

About the author

Ian Bell

Brandon bureau

explore

Stories from our other publications