Loss of Crow rate shows in census

Reading Time: 2 minutes

Published: May 23, 2002

Finally, says senior Agriculture Canada senior analyst David Culver,

the government is seeing concrete results from its 1995 decision to

abolish the historic prairie grain transportation subsidy.

They come in the first results of the 2001 census of agriculture

published May 15 that show prairie wheat acreage down and strong growth

in livestock numbers and acreage of alternative crops.

“I think we are starting to see some of the changes flowing from policy

changes,” Culver said May 16. “Pulse crops, hog farms, livestock. Some

Read Also

An aerial view of the

Increasing farmland prices blamed on investors

a major tax and financial services firm says investors are driving up the value of farmland, preventing young farmers from entering the business. Robert Andjelic said that is bullshit.

of those changes are amazing. I think it is positive.”

On the Prairies, farmers and economists agree that the end of the Crow

Benefit rail transportation subsidy set in motion events and farmer

decisions that are reflected in changing farming patterns reported in

the census.

“It has made grain farming that much less profitable at a time when

prices are down and other countries are increasing subsidies rather

than cutting them,” Canadian Federation of Agriculture vice-president

and former Saskatchewan Wheat Pool vice-president Marvin Shauf said May

17. The industry, still one of the key prairie farm sectors, is weaker

for it.

“I think the loss of the Crow really was a pivotal point,” agreed

University of Saskatchewan agricultural economist Rose Olfert. “The

trends that we see now will continue to show up and perhaps accelerate.”

The trends were notable across the Prairies.

In Saskatchewan, although wheat remains the king crop in area planted,

wheat acres declined by more than 16 percent to 15.2 million acres.

Field pea and lentil acreage more than doubled in 2001 and more than

one million acres were planted to chickpeas.

Alberta, Canada’s largest agricultural province, increased its cattle

herd by 6.6 million head to give it 43 percent of the national herd and

saw potato acreage increase 85 percent.

In Manitoba, wheat remained the biggest single grain crop but more than

one-third of Manitoba farms are cattle operations.

“With the removal of the Western Grain Transportation Act in 1995,

transportation costs to grain producers increased,” said the Statistics

Canada census analysis. “This, along with decreasing grain prices and

increasing livestock prices, made the feeding of livestock a good

alternative to selling grain.”

Culver said this reaction was a few years late in coming.

When the WGTA was abolished and a $1.6 billion Crow buyout was offered

in 1996, the government expected grain farmers to quickly get the

message that exporting raw grain was not good business. Instead, little

changed at first because grain prices were high in the mid-1990s and

the full impact of higher transportation costs were masked.

In Foremost, Alta., Brenda Stryker said her farm and her neighbours

have reacted to prices and policy changes by trying to avoid crops that

do not return a profit or that must be marketed through the Canadian

Wheat Board.

Still, this year also illustrates that some existing policies still

influence farmer planting decisions.

On their 6,000 acre farm in southeastern Alberta, the Strykers are

seeding more than a normal acreage of wheat and durum this year – low

priced crops that are marketed through the CWB.

The reason is the weather. The area has been bone dry for several years

and even late spring snow has not been enough.

“We’re planting more than normal acres of wheat and durum because of

crop insurance,” she said May 17.

“We don’t normally plant for crop insurance but this year, we need to

be cautious. We can’t afford to not have revenue from those acres.”

explore

Stories from our other publications