The European Commission’s decision to not ban a class of insecticides because of their potential threat to bees is prudent, says a University of Guelph entomologist.
Representatives of European Union member states voted March 15 on a proposal to ban three neonicotinoids for two years in all 27 countries.
The three neonicotinoids — thiamethoxam, clothianidin and imidacloprid — are applied primarily as a seed treatment to millions of acres of corn, soybeans, canola and sunflowers around the world.
Opinion polls indicated robust public support for the ban, but British and German politicians voted against it and defeated the proposal, the Guardian newspaper reported.
Read Also
Manitoba Parkland research station grapples with dry year
Drought conditions in northwestern Manitoba have forced researchers at the Parkland Crop Diversification Foundation to terminate some projects and reseed others.
“Britain and Germany have caved in to the industry lobby and refused to ban bee-killing pesticides,” said Iain Keith of Avaaz, a campaign organization.
“Today’s vote flies in the face of science and public opinion and maintains the disastrous chemical armageddon on bees, which are critical for the future of our food.”
Peter Kevan, a professor of environmental biology at the U of G, rejected the anti-neonicotinoid rhetoric.
“At this stage it would be premature to ban them….There (isn’t) sufficient data to say they (neonicotinoids) are as dangerous as has been made out,” said Kevan, who heads Canpolin, a network of scientists studying the decline of bees in agricultural and natural ecosystems in Canada.
“There’s very little evidence to say that neonicotinoids, in a very general sense, in a broad scale sense, have been a major component in the demise of honeybees or any other pollinators, anywhere in the world.”
Kevan said neonicotinoid seed treatments have damaged bee colonies in specific cases around the globe. For example, last spring thousands of bees died in southern Ontario when dust from corn planters containing neonic treated seed blew onto plants and flowers near honeybee hives.
However, he said those cases are incidents rather than a systemic agricultural risk to bees, which has “been purported by some people.”
Kevan agreed the issue has become highly political in Europe as the furor of environmental groups and the media have pushed bees and neonics into the spotlight.
“The rhetoric has gotten ahead of the science.”
Nonetheless, he said certain studies have raised red flags regarding neonicotinoids.
