Milk and medicine; malpractice cases – Health Clinic

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Published: March 7, 2002

Q:I suffer from acne and my doctor has given me tetracycline to take

for a year or more. He has told me not to take it with milk because it

interferes with the medicine’s action. Is there anything else I should

be careful not to take it with?

A: Tetracycline, also known as achromycin or sumycin, is an antibiotic

often used in the treatment of severe acne and other infections,

usually lung conditions such as bronchitis. It is not a powerful drug

Read Also

Two women work in a restaurant kitchen, one crumbling rice into a large, clear container with her hands while the other holds a shallow metal pan upside down.

Restaurant blends zero waste, ancient farming

A Mexico City restaurant has become a draw for its zero-waste kitchen, which means that every scrap of food and leftovers is reused for other purposes.

since it slows down the bacteria’s rate of reproduction rather than

killing it. This allows the body’s natural defence mechanisms to work.

Because it is less likely to wipe out the good bacteria in the

intestines and vagina, secondary yeast infections

are not as common, and therefore tetracycline is a good choice for

long-term use.

However, there are some drawbacks as you mentioned. Tetracycline does

interact with milk, cheese and other substances containing calcium,

making it less effective. It also reacts with other minerals such as

magnesium and aluminum, and to some extent iron and zinc.

These are commonly found in antacids and vitamin tablets. It can also

interfere with the activity of potassium, and the vitamins B2, B6, B12,

C, K and folic acid. This is not a problem for a person who only needs

to take it for a couple of weeks, but for long-term use, you might want

to supplement B and C vitamins.

Regular tetracycline is usually taken four times a day, which makes it

inconvenient to avoid the dairy products. An alternative would be

doxycycline or minocycline (Minocin).

These need only be taken twice a day, even for more severe infections,

and are much less likely to be interfered with by the above mentioned

minerals, dairy products and antacids.

There is always a catch. These drugs are much more expensive and have

other side effects, such as stomach irritation and dizziness in some

patients.

None of these medications should be given to children or pregnant

women. They can cause a yellow discolouration of the teeth in the

developing child.

Q: How often do doctors make mistakes?

A:I know from reading reports from the College of Physicians and

Surgeons that there are one or two cases a year in Canada where doctors

are investigated for claims of medical malpractice. Half of those cases

find the doctor guilty.

Malpractice means that most doctors dealing with a similar condition

would have done things differently. It does not necessarily mean the

doctor has to always be right. He is allowed to make some mistakes or

human errors, as long as other doctors might have easily made the same

mistake. For example, some

diagnoses are difficult to make.

Actually, more mistakes occur in the dispensing of medications by

pharmacists or nurses. It is important to always check that you have

the correct prescription. If it doesn’t look right, don’t hesitate to

question it.

Unfortunately, in nursing homes, the patients are often too debilitated

to notice what they are taking. On the positive side, a lot of them are

taking the same medications so these mistakes are rarely fatal.

If you want to check statistics further, I suggest you look into the

College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta at www.cpsa.ab.ca. The

college looks after your rights as a patient or patient’s relative.

In the year 2000, it received 365 complaints regarding quality of

patient care. Of all the complaints, and this included problems with

files and office management, only five went as far as a formal hearing.

Clare Rowson is a medical doctor with a practice near Belleville, Ont.

Her columns are intended for general information only. Individuals are

encouraged to also seek the advice of their own doctor regarding

medical questions and treatments.

explore

Stories from our other publications