Tensions run high over use of creek water

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Published: August 1, 2002

Sask Water is fielding more complaints than usual this year from

farmers concerned that their neighbours are not sharing water.

Don Dill, regional water resource manager for the Saskatchewan crown

corporation in North Battleford, Sask., said the situation is

especially acute in western and northern

regions.

“There are many, many desperate people out there,” he said.

There has been little or no spring runoff to fill dugouts, and springs

that normally flow in July have dried up.

Read Also

A stock photo of some dark storm clouds with an obvious downpour happening over farm land in the middle of the image.

Extreme rain increases as planet warms

In this issue, we are going to wrap up our look at extreme rainfall by examining the different weather patterns that tend to be associated with these rainfall events.

“I don’t think I’ve ever seen it as bad.”

He said Sask Water’s job is to separate fact from fiction, steer clear

of personal issues and keep focused on the legislation outlining how

farmers access water.

One of this year’s complaints came from Frank Blair of Herschel, Sask.

He said that springs usually run down from nearby hills to his land to

fill a dugout and refresh Eagle Creek.

But that didn’t happen this year and he contacted Sask Water to point

the blame at his neighbour, Berny Wiens.

“My cows are drinking out of a stagnant old pool at Eagle Creek. My

cows are getting thin,” Blair said.

“All I want is just a little water going through for my cattle.”

Wiens, a former provincial NDP cabinet minister, argued there is enough

water in the 21/2 kilometres of Eagle Creek that flows through the

cattle pasture.

He also said he has not created new dams, but restored a Prairie Farm

Rehabilitation Administration dam and irrigation project that were

created for market gardening in the 1930s.

Wiens grows cantaloupes, watermelons and pumpkins, and has stocked a

pond with fish. He also built a beach and floating dock in hopes of

bringing more tourism to the region.

Blair said some of Wiens’s fish eventually end up in his dugout, where

they are not wanted.

The area has had successive years of dry weather, and conditions have

been made worse by this year’s drought.

Ian Burns, also desperate to find enough water for his cattle, has 10

head bunking in with Blair’s cattle.

He doesn’t think Wiens should be able to block the stream, especially

in a drought.

“Every drop counts,” he said.

Burns said that without water, he will be forced to truck his animals

to pastures in the south. Blair also will have to move his cattle to

other pastures on his land.

Blair thinks Sask Water is treating Wiens differently than other

irrigators because of his political connections to the provincial

government.

Sask Water denies that and recently asked Wiens to release more water

to fill Blair’s dugout.

“We need to treat him, and do treat him, the same as we do anybody

else,” Dill said.

He said water and drainage stir up passions among users.

“People often use water to get back at somebody else.”

Sask Water has advised Blair to create another dugout to protect

against future drought, but Blair argues that would cost him money and

is unnecessary.

“Why should I build a dugout? I can’t afford thousands of dollars to

accommodate Berny Wiens and Sask Water.”

Dill said farmers are allowed to use water flowing through their

properties for domestic purposes. However, they are required to obtain

permits from Sask Water if the water is diverted or dammed.

Because Wiens made changes to his irrigation system, he is required to

obtain approval and a new irrigation certificate from Sask Water, Dill

said.

Farmers must also get approval before and following construction of new

irrigation works.

“Sometimes with irrigators, they put these things up and we get

involved after the fact,” Dill said.

“This is one of these situations.”

Dill said Wiens is drawing up a water-use plan for Sask Water that must

accommodate downstream

  • eeds.

“You need to make sure (Blair) has a similar situation as he would

under natural conditions,” Dill said.

“That’s up to us to make sure that now happens.”

Sask Water plans to evaluate whether drought, Wiens’s horticultural

enterprise or both have caused water shortages on Blair’s farm.

In the meantime, Wiens said he is prepared to co-operate with Sask

Water.

“When they want a release, I’ll make a release,” he said.

About the author

Karen Morrison

Saskatoon newsroom

explore

Stories from our other publications