Crude oil and canola part company – for now

WINNIPEG – The symbiotic relationship that crude oil and canola used to enjoy seems to have hit a snag.

Chart structures have proven that crude prices have pushed and pulled canola up and down in recent years.

However, since the start of 2018, the gains enjoyed by crude oil have failed to lift canola.

On Jan. 10, the cost of a barrel of oil on the New York Mercantile Exchange was US$61.82. Now, that same barrel is closer to US$71.

Canola on the other hand has fallen from the C$505 per tonne mark down to the C$485 per tonne mark, as of Friday’s close.

According to Mike Jubinville of ProFarmer Canada (which is owned by The Western Producer’s parent company, Glacier FarmMedia), the link that existed between the two has been disrupted by the global trade disruptions emanating from the White House, and to a lesser extent China.

He says the relationship between the two commodities should eventually return though.

“We’ll swing back to traditional relationships between commodities but there are periods of time of disconnect and right now is one of them,” he said.

Another market-watcher also agreed that crude’s influence on canola seems to have waned.

“I don’t really look at crude as a canola indicator very much anymore,” said Errol Anderson, President of ProMarket Communications. He added crude oil has turned into a manipulated market from global players and tends to be focused on issues stemming from the Middle East.

To understand the influence crude oil initially had on canola though, one first has to look at energy.

Canola, like many other vegetable oils, has a stake in the bio-diesel market. So when crude oil is moving one way or the other bio-diesel will get caught up in its wake. That bias is eventually transferred down to things like European rapeseed futures, Malaysian palm oil and eventually canola.

Crude is also considered a leader in the market as it is the highest traded commodity by volume and by valuation.

Thirdly, when crude oil is on the move it always attracts the interest of the speculative community.

“If crude is making a move higher and you have a lot of spec money that wants to enter commodities, and they spread it around, you get some residual effect on the ag sector,” Jubinville explained.

He adds commercials will also get more interested in buying up commodities like canola if crude makes a jump higher.

However, for now, the escalating trade battle between the U.S. and China and unpredictability of President Donald Trump continues to cancel out most other influences.

“The microcosms of Trumps’ tweets are the short-term influence that we are under now,” said Jubinville.

About the author


Stories from our other publications