Compensation from failed firm likely small

A CGC spokeperson says the size of NSGL's security bond was too small to ensure full compensation to all eligible claimants. Farmers who sold grain to Naber Specialty Grains will likely receive 10 to 15 percent of what they were owed. | WP photo illustration

Farmers who sold grain to a bankrupt elevator company and were never paid will likely receive 10 to 15 percent of what they were owed.

Naber Specialty Grains Ltd. (NSGL) of Melfort, Sask., was placed in receivership last year.

The company had posted a $150,000 security bond with the Can-adian Grain Commission before it ran into financial difficulty.

However, CGC spokesperson Remi Gosselin said the size of NSGL’s security bond was too small to ensure full compensation to all eligible claimants.

“At this point in time, it’s clear that the security that was posted by the company (NSGL) to compensate grain producers will be insufficient,” Gosselin said.

The commission has also referred the matter to the RCMP, after un-covering what Gosselin called “apparent irregularities.”

“We’ve referred the matter to the RCMP because of the magnitude of the company’s outstanding liabilities to producers at the time of receivership and also the extent to which those liabilities may have been under-reported in reports to the grain commission,” he said.

The grain commission’s payment protection program requires all licensed elevator companies in Canada to post a security bond with the commission.

NSGL posted a bond, but it now appears it was significantly undersized, based on the value of grain deliveries to NSGL and unsettled accounts with farmers.

Total eligible farm claims against NSGL are estimated to be $1 million to $1.5 million, although Gosselin declined to provide a specific number.

The payment protection program requires licensed elevator companies to submit monthly reports to the CGC, summarizing the value of grain receipts and inventories.

The commission uses the reports to ensure that the company’s security bond is of an adequate size.

Lee Egland, a producer from Eastend, Sask., said someone at the commission dropped the ball.

Egland sold near $90,000 worth of flax to NSGL in March 2015 but didn’t receive a penny in payment.

He said the grain commission must do a better job of managing its payment protection program if it hopes to provide a reasonable level of security to farmers.

“The CGC or the government is not looking after producers when they’ve got a … bond that size,” he said. “The total bond that they made Naber pay was 150 grand, (but) my loss alone is half of that. That’s not a very good deal.”

Gosselin said the CGC audits licensed companies when financial irregularities come to light. Random audits are also conducted.

The grain commission conducted an audit of NSGL’s operations in March 2015 after receiving complaints from farmers about late payments and difficulties getting grain tickets. It instructed NSGL in April to settle outstanding accounts with farmers. Later the same month, it instructed NSGL to stop taking deliveries of farmers’ grain.

NSGL’s elevator licence was not renewed after May 8, 2015.

About the author


Stories from our other publications