Battle of the beans

WINNIPEG/CHICAGO — Monsanto is facing major threats to its historic dominance of seed and herbicide technology for the $40 billion U.S. soybean market.

Rivals BASF and DowDuPont are preparing to push their own varieties of genetically modified soybeans. At stake is control over seed supply for the next generation of farmers producing the most valuable U.S. agricultural export.

The market has opened up because Monsanto’s Roundup Ready varieties, which are modified to tolerate glyphosate, have lost effectiveness as weeds develop their own tolerance to the chemical. Compounding the firm’s troubles is a national scandal over crop damage linked to its new soybean and herbicide pairing — Roundup Ready 2 Xtend seeds, modified to resist dicamba.

The newly competitive sector has sown confusion across the U.S. farm belt, particularly among smaller firms that produce and sell seeds with technology licensed from the agrichemical giants.

Many of these sellers said they are amassing a surplus of seeds with modified traits from multiple developers — at substantial extra cost — because they can only guess which product farmers will buy.

“Our job is to meet our customers’ needs, and we don’t know what those are going to be,” said Carl Peterson, president of Peterson Farms Seed near Fargo, North Dakota.

“I don’t think I’ve ever seen anything quite like this.”

Monsanto has much to lose. Soybeans are the key ingredient in feed used to fatten the world’s cattle, pigs, chickens and fish.

Net sales of Monsanto’s soybean seeds and traits totalled almost $2.7 billion in fiscal 2017, or about a fifth of its total net sales. Gross profits from soybean products climbed 35 percent from 2016, beating 15 percent growth of its bigger corn seed franchise.

The firm faces multiple lawsuits, along with regulatory restrictions in some U.S. states, because dicamba has drifted onto neighbouring farms and fields and damaged crops not genetically modified to resist it.

However, BASF and DowDuPont have their own obstacles to overcome, fueling unprecedented uncertainty among farmers over which seeds they will plant on 90 million acres of U.S. farmland this spring.

BASF is just entering the market, aiming to compete with an older soybean line called LibertyLink, which the firm is acquiring from Bayer.

As well, DowDuPont is eager to join the fray but needs approval from Chinese regulators before it can broadly market and sell its new soybean product, Enlist E3.

Monsanto declined comment on competition from rivals in the soybean market, but the firm has previously acknowledged the intensifying threat to its bottom line as rivals launch new products.

“Our competitors’ success could render our existing products less competitive, resulting in reduced sales compared to our expectations or past results,” Monsanto said in an annual report filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission last year.

The name of Monsanto’s new dicamba-based herbicide — XtendiMax with VaporGrip — reflects the problem it tries to solve: the chemical’s tendency to vaporize and drift to neighboring fields, damaging crops.

But last summer, after farmers planted Monsanto’s new dicamba-resistant seeds en masse, the herbicide damaged an estimated 3.6 million acres of soybeans, or four percent of all U.S. plantings.

Monsanto maintains that its new formulation of dicamba reduces drift effectively. Instead, it blames farmers for not following spraying instructions and for illegally applying older versions of dicamba on Xtend seeds.

Despite the controversy, the Xtend variety has sold briskly, spanning 20 million U.S. acres in 2017, its second year of sales. Monsanto projects that acreage will double this year, accounting for about 44 percent of all planted acres.

Still, Monsanto faces a slew of regulatory, legal and public relations challenges from the crop-damage crisis.

Regulators in Arkansas, where crops were heavily damaged in 2017, have prohibited the use of dicamba-based herbicides between dates that likely will cover the entire growing season. Missouri, Minnesota and North Dakota have also restricted when farmers can spray dicamba.

Missouri farmer Bobby Aycock joined one of several class-action lawsuits against Monsanto after dicamba spraying by nearby farmers damaged his crops in 2016.

He then planted Xtend in 2017 to ensure that drifting dicamba could not harm his crop again. He found another benefit at harvest time: his highest yield in 33 years of soybean farming.

Despite his lawsuit against Monsanto, Aycock plans to sow Xtend seeds again this spring.

”If something’s working, I hate to change it,” he said.

BASF is waiting for Monsanto and Bayer to close their proposed $63.5 billion merger before it can take over Bayer’s LibertyLink brand of seeds, which are modified to withstand the chemical glufosinate.

The timing of the takeover, expected in the spring planting season, is awkward because farmers may have already bought seeds. BASF aims to prevent any “customer disruption” when it assumes control of the LibertyLink brand as part of a $7 billion deal with Bayer, said BASF vice-president Scott Kay.

BASF declined to elaborate further on its strategy because the purchase of LibertyLink is not yet completed.

The acquisition complements BASF’s herbicide business with a seed line that should “continue to grow profitably,” outgoing BASF chief executive officer Kurt Bock said in October.

Bayer has sold LibertyLink in the United States since 2009, steadily gaining market share to reach about 15 percent, said Rob Schrick, who runs North American corn and soybean strategy for Bayer. The company expects the brand to capture 20 percent of the market this year.

BASF had a strategic urgency in the LibertyLink acquisition, said Patrick Jahnke, portfolio manager at Deka Investments, which owns BASF stock.

“The Bayer seed assets were not a bargain,” Jahnke said.

“But the purchase eliminates the risk of being the only major supplier in the agro business without a seeds offering.”

DowDuPont faces the greatest obstacle in the fight for soybean market share because it is waiting for Chinese regulators to approve imports of soybeans harvested from its Enlist E3 seeds.

Enlist E3 soybeans are bred to resist glyphosate, glufosinate and 2,4-D, a chemical with roots stretching to the Vietnam War as an ingredient in Agent Orange, used by the U.S. military to defoliate jungle.

Launching Enlist widely without Beijing’s approval would risk causing unapproved soybeans to be inadvertently shipped to China, the biggest importer. So for now, DowDuPont’s seeds will be grown by a limited, undisclosed number of U.S. farmers who agree to deliver their harvests only to facilities run by Archer Daniels Midland, according to the company.

The deal will give Enlist — one of DowDuPont’s biggest crop-system investments — a toehold in the U.S. market. Approval by Chinese regulators, which is an uncertain process, could translate to huge profits, but DowDuPont would still face the challenge of catching rivals who have a head start, said Michael Underhill, chief investment officer of Capital Innovations, which manages shares of DowDuPont, Bayer and Monsanto.

“To go into this market, and be late to the game, you have to be exceedingly aggressive,” Underhill said.

DowDuPont’s entry makes it especially hard for farmers to decide what to buy because Enlist E3 may or may not be widely available, said Mark Denzler, president of Indiana-based 1st Choice Seeds, which scooped up surplus soybean seeds last autumn.

In Iowa, Stine Seed acquired 238 billion extra soybean seeds to sell because of the uncertainty, CEO Harry Stine said.

Illinois-based Great Heart Seed has amassed extra supplies of five varieties of genetically modified soybeans.

”It’s a real pain and it will continue to be so going forward, trying to manage the inventory,” said company co-owner Nels Kasey.

Like the seed sellers, Missouri farmer Milas Mainord plans to hedge his bets by planting at least three soybean varieties.

He will devote up to 30 percent of his 5,000 acres of soybeans to Monsanto’s Xtend seeds to protect himself from neighbours spraying dicamba. He also plans to plant some LibertyLink and other varieties in areas where he doesn’t expect dicamba use.

“We’re covering our bases,” Mainord said.

About the author


Stories from our other publications