Letters to the editor – August 20, 2015


Resource management

Canada must pass laws to protect water and the environment because it takes “pathetic care” of the nations water resources.

This was the main message from Maude Barlow, who was a keynote speaker at Water Awareness Day, that recently took place at the recreation centre in Matlock, Man.

Yes, sorely, Canada does not have much of a record, except a poor one, when it concerns the protection of our environment, water sources and climate.

Looking at this planet and especially after seeing Lake Winnipeg or the Athabasca Tar Sands devastation, any visitor from outer space would say “I want to see the manager”.

It is too easy for many of us living in Canada to take our wonderful waters, our blood of life, for granted, and reading the grim message of the pathetic care of our nation’s water resources, by Ms. Barlow, only bolsters the desperate need for a Canada Water Commissioner.

Science has long identified the source of the problems with the Lake Winnipeg waters and many other Canadian lakes and waters experiencing massive eutrophication. For more than 40 years, study after study, arrived at a consensus: over-fertilization of our fresh waters.


In 1974,co-author of The Algal Bowl, scientist John R. Vallentyne, predicted that we would be living with an environmental disaster he called the algal bowl by the year 2000. Just as the Dust Bowl of the 1930s was created by misusing western farmland,he forecast that continued misuse of lakes would also lead to water degradation. To-day, waters suffer from our ignorance and denial. His predictions have been realized.

Science also tells us Lake Winnipeg water recovery is costly and takes time. Having failed to heed the warnings,the most cost effective approach now is to reduce inputs and wait for decades, for the symptoms of eutrophication to subside.

It is clear that all government levels have ignored the basic needs and principles of water stewardship for many years in the pursuit of narrow economic interests. The grim consequences are now a sounding board of our negligence.

Lake Winnipeg has become a horrid reminder of shameful devastation, a repercussion that we are leaving our children and their children to bear alone.

John Fefchak,
Virden, Man.


  • Denise

    I guess we”ll get what we deserve. What a shame for future generations .We had it all and didn’t respect it. Only California can appreciate the shame of it all.

  • old grouchy

    Such a shame, that over fertilization, we need all the farmers to stop using fertilizers, especially organic ones – – – of course the large increase in butts in Winnipeg and the huge developments around the lake have nothing to do with any of this issue – – – right?

    • John Fefchak

      Those are your words,.. ,,not mine.

      There are many contributors that pollute our waters and Lake Winnipeg. leading to water degradation and experiencing massive eutrophication. If you truly have a genuine interest I suggest that you read the book,1974 Algal Bowl. At least, it may provide you with some information that you never realized of what and why this is happening.

    • ed

      You may be correct about the fertilizer part of things. Commerce for devastation sake alone makes little sense in a world awash in grain.